Rank | Team | |
---|---|---|
1 | Connecticut | |
2 | North Carolina | |
3 | Duke | |
4 | Pittsburgh | |
5 | Memphis | |
6 | Oklahoma | |
7 | Wake Forest | |
8 | UCLA | |
9 | Clemson | |
10 | Michigan St. | |
11 | Butler | |
12 | Xavier | |
13 | Marquette | |
14 | Dayton | |
15 | Utah St. | |
16 | Missouri | |
17 | Villanova | |
18 | Louisville | |
19 | Kansas | |
20 | Louisiana St. | |
21 | Davidson | |
22 | Florida | |
23 | Illinois | |
24 | Arizona St. | |
25 | Gonzaga |
I offer along with this ballot an apology - it's in no way scientific or even particularly thorough in its thought process. It's written under the influence of a time crunch as well as extreme soreness and a pretty fair amount of fatigue - six hours ago, I was wrapping up my second straight seven-hour day on the ski slopes. Don't be jealous just 'cause I had an awesome weekend. It's at least a defendable ballot, though.
In the future, my rankings will very certainly be crunched by the numbers. How exactly, I don't know, but they'll involve the following:
- Some combination of the Pomeroy and RPI rankings. Pomeroy intends his rankings to be entirely predictive; RPI, like the Blogpoll rankings, is supposed to be based on resume.
- Some way of tabulating the value of the out-of-conference wins and losses on each team's schedule based on the above combination.
- Some involvement of strength of schedule.
- Some way of ranking the conferences. One major distinction I plan on making between the football and basketball rankings is this: I don't intend to take into account individual wins and losses within the conference. In football, the national championship demands perfection or near-perfection; in basketball, the quest for perfection is just a silly game the media plays. If Florida is going for the national football title, losing to a crappy team like Arkansas is a major crippling blow to their chances, and it's reflected in the rankings. If Florida's basketball team is a national title contender and loses to a crappy team like Arkansas, it hardly matters. Everyone has losses like that on their resume anyway. I'll take into account a team's record in conference play and which conference they play in, rather than who exactly they beat or lost to. So conference rankings matter - UNC's 7-2 is certainly more impressive than Miami (Ohio)'s 7-2. Out of conference, individual games - and their locations - do matter.
No comments:
Post a Comment