Wednesday, October 6, 2010

q&a with From The Rumble Seat

In what has become a thrice-yearly tradition (for football, basketball, and baseball, and it's a shame there's no lacrosse team there), it's just not Georgia Tech week without trading a Q&A with the engineer types at From The Rumble Seat, as ever the finest GT blog around. Here are their answers to the questions I had for them; soon enough you'll be able to read what I gave 'em for answers. Always a good way to find out what the opposition thinks is important about UVA football.

1. Seriously, what's going on? NC State gashed your defense and if Wake Forest wasn't the ACC's second-worst team and using their 4th-string QB, I doubt GT would have pulled that one out either. Is the offense out of sync? Any buyer's remorse with Groh? What's the one biggest problem that needs to get fixed lest GT end up in the Emerald Bowl?

FTRS: Defensively, Al Groh said it best when he said, "There’s no supermarket we can go down to and buy new players. This is our team as constituted." We lost our two most talented players to the NFL draft last season and returned everyone else from a relatively middle of the road 2009 defense. Factor in the transition to the Grohfense and we've got a fair amount of confusion, lack of 3-4 style players, and bad luck. There is no buyer's remorse, however, as most Tech fans are happy with the fundamental football we're seeing from our defense. Guys aren't flying past the ball carrier, missing tackles or completely leaving guys wide open in the passing game. It's just a work in progress on defense.

Offensively, we've had poor execution, untimely injuries, and lost talent to the NFL. Not having a dominant wide receiver has been pretty frustrating. Tech fans have watched at least one first round receiver play football at Tech since 2004. Now, it's only natural to compare our current stable to their predecessors (Calvin and Demaryius) and the comparisons haven't really materialized. Oh and we're fumbling about 40% more often than in 2009. That really hurts an option team.


2. Leaving personnel out of it, do you prefer the old 4-3 or Groh's 3-4 as a way to deal with ACC offenses?

FTRS: Our 4-3 was awful under Dave Wommack particularly in 2009. It couldn't stop a JV offense. In 2010, the 3-4 is still a work in progress. I think Tech fans will definitely give Groh a couple years to build up some decent talent before we judge him harshly. Wommack came in as a 4-2-5 guy and had all of Tenuta's well-coached-up guys to shield his inadequacies as a coordinator in 2008. When a majority of them left, the lack of adjustments and poor fundamental football made GT's 2009 defense fairly inept.

3. Let's assume Groh has impeccable knowledge of UVA's tendencies and personnel and is devising a brilliant scheme that will shut down the UVA offense if perfectly executed. What should UVA do to avoid that? What players on GT's defense should UVA focus on avoiding and what weaknesses should they try to attack?

FTRS: I recommend starting everyone on your scout team against Tech. That way Groh has no idea what GT will do to counterattack it. If the guy doesn't have a scholarship, he better be starting on Saturday. (Editor's note: here's where I'm tempted to make a crack about how you can't tell the difference, but I think the offense will look better this week than last.)

Since the season started, most teams have avoided running towards Brad Jefferson. He is playing one of the inside linebacker spots and has essentially herded opposing offenses to the opposite side of the field. Jerrard Tarrant is a play maker at corner and safety but is also highly susceptible to being burned. Our weak points are all over the field. We have an inexperienced, yet talented safety in freshman Isaiah Johnson. Our defensive line applies minimal pressure and our linebackers are often out of position. Your offense should find some success.

4. A lot of UVA fans really, really want to beat Al Groh. Is there any win-one-for-the-Grohster feeling, going up against his old team, among GT fans?

FTRS: GT fans really dislike UVA because UVA is the fly in the soup of GT. 2008 is the perfect example. UVA wasn't the best team ever coming into GT's 2008 homecoming. When UVA left, they had ended a 12 game homecoming win streak and essentially ruined GT's shot at an ACC Coastal Title. (Editor's note: Oopsy-daisy.) Oh and UVA is 12-7 against GT since the epic 1990 game (including an 8-1 home record). Al Groh just throws fuel on the fire for most GT fans. We want to beat UVA already and Al Groh adds a little spice to the hate-filled burrito that is the GT fan base.

5. Seriously, I hate being other teams' homecoming opponent (except when we win). Couldn't you have waited a week and had it against MTSU instead?

FTRS: I don't really know what goes into the selection of homecoming dates. Looking back over the year, the homecoming game has averaged about 1,000 more people per contest than average football games at Bobby Dodd. And we try to schedule the last home game in October. I guess Dan Radakovich felt that UVA was more enticing for GT alums to attend than MTSU. (Editor's note: Smart man.) It was probably a mutual decision between the Alumni Association, Athletic Association, and City of Atlanta (for traffic). Generally speaking, we don't schedule patsies on homecoming as the last six were UVA, VT, UVA, Army, Miami, and Clemson.

Tuesday, October 5, 2010

i want a nine-game conference schedule

This is something I get around to thinking about every year, and it's always right around the time UVA plays a game against a conference opponent that it hasn't seen in four years. The current ACC schedule rotation isn't bad as far as things go: it's easily comprehended, it preserves rivalries, and it keeps the suits happy with the dolla dolla bill y'all possibility of a Miami-FSU ACCCG. There's one gaping, ugly flaw, though: the idea that we share a conference with five schools with whom a home football game is a less common occurrence than a presidential election. Seriously, how much of a conference is it when you go four years in between playing a team? Next time there's a UVA-Clemson game - and these are two of the ACC's old guard, mind you, and still we play Miami every year - it will be 2013.

A couple different solutions exist that keep the schedule at eight games, but all are unpalatable. The Big 12 only has a two-season (three-year) gap in between games with various opponents, but they don't have cross-division rivalries: a must if we're to keep playing Maryland and the divisions aren't realigned. There's a way to set up a more convoluted rotation, which does fix the long gap in between playing a team but doesn't do anything about the five-year game between home games against them.

The Pac-10 plays nine conference games and probably will continue to do so as the Pac-12. The Big Ten is considering it. Why not the ACC? Virginia plays Idaho next season. I'm excited, I'll show you. Wait for it...

YIPPEE

I have no problem at all with the idea of sacrificing games against Idaho and UTSA to get another conference game. Would UVA lose much revenue? Nope. The major barrier to a nine-game conference schedule for the Big Ten is the possibility that schools like Michigan and Ohio State would balk at losing a home game every other year. They'll fill the stadium playing Pee Wee's Preschool. UVA is visiting UTSA. Revenue: not a thing for us. Probably would come out better, actually.

(I do realize that the way ADs think, we'd probably lose the Penn State-type games instead of the UTSAs and VMIs, but let's pretend for a minute that won't happen. Because even if we do I want a nine-game conference schedule.)

Now, how to set this up? This is important. "I want a nine-game schedule" is a phrase, not a post. Propose a solution, don't just bring up a problem. Right? I see three good ways this can be done.

#1: The Convolusion

- Keep the single cross-division rivalry.
- Add one extra non-rival, cross-division opponent to the schedule.
- Rotate as follows:



Basically, that's sharing a permanent rivalry with team #1, and playing teams 2, 3, and 4; then 5, 6, and 2; then 3, 4, and 5; and so on. Grayed-out helmets are road games. Please don't harass me about this not fitting with the current schedule. The teams are interchangeable, it's just easier to show a picture.

Best part: A matchup would only ever take a season off, at most. Three home games instead of two against any opponent in a ten-year period, and at most four years instead of five in between them; usually fewer.

It's a lot more complex than what we have now. The current rotation is easy to memorize; this isn't. It'd result in endless posts on every message board, every season, asking "hay guyz what teams we play next year?!?" that would cause more conscientious folks to roll their eyes and provide the link to the ACC rotation schedule. Because it's posted now and it'd be posted again.

Plus, it would lead to potential Horrible Injustices. Well, not that horrible. But it takes ten years to fully rotate through to the beginning again; the current one only takes five.

#2: The Get Pumped For A Made For TV Rivalry

This involves a second permanent cross-division rival. UVA doesn't really have a natural candidate for that, except maybe FSU because of the cooked-up Jefferson-Eppes trophy. But it makes the rotation a lot simpler:
Again, the teams are interchangeable. It doesn't have to be Clemson.

This way any dummy ought to know when the next game against someone is. Again, only one season in between games against someone. Three seasons in between home games with a non-rival opponent. The downside is, you're going to have a lot of complaining about the assignment of a new rival ("Johnny got a bigger cupcake with more frosting than I did!"), but hell: you can easily swap rivals after four years. Let the ACC reassign rivals every four years based on the past four years of performances; intrigue awaits.

#3: The Realignment

Easy: just change the divisions, like this:

Atlantic:

Boston College
Clemson
Florida State
Georgia Tech
Miami
Wake Forest

Coastal:

Duke
Maryland
North Carolina
NC State
Virginia
Virginia Tech

See what I did there? Yup, I just swapped GT and Miami for Maryland and NC State, is all. It preserves every actual rivalry and four of six current cross-division ones. And then, eliminate the cross-division rival thing. (Sorry, Duke-Wake and VT-BC.) After that it's a no-brainer to set up four games against the other division, and swap two teams out each season, rotating like so:

That's actually two full iterations. Such is the elegant simplicity. The teams are still interchangeable - that is, I don't care about the order, but the divisions are a must since I'm a UVA fans and UVA fans want to play a certain three teams every year. I suppose if you wanted to, you could take it a step further, swap BC with Duke or NC State, and make it North and South. NC State would squawk like hell though, their only real rival in the conference is UNC, and who knows how much UNC and Duke care about playing each other in football? It's an awfully lopsided series; I doubt Duke gives a damn.

This is the least likely because it requires the conference suits to give on their precious idea of a Miami-FSU ACCCG. But it's the most appealingly simple.

Nine games: I wants them. If the ACC expands any more, I definitely wants them, otherwise the gap in between playing these teams also expands accordingly, and at that point do you really even have a conference?

Final note: I did think about even more creative solutions, involving four divisions of three and whatnot. But that's impossible unless you want to get rid of the ACCCG, which will happen only after little green men blow up the ACC offices with proton guns. Because:

Regarding Conference Championship Games, NCAA bylaw 17.9.5.2 (c) states:

"Annual Exemptions. [FBS/FCS] The maximum number of football contests shall exclude the following:
.
.
.

(c) Twelve-Member Conference Championship Game. [FBS/FCS] A conference championship game between division champions of a member conference of 12 or more institutions that is divided into two divisions (of six or more institutions each), each of which conducts round-robin, regular-season competition among the members of that division..."


So you see.

Anyway, you know what I like. The poll at right is for you to decide what you like.

Monday, October 4, 2010

weekend review

Monday again. That means it's time to update the recruiting board, yep. Lot of shuffling....

- Moved CB Demetrious Nicholson and LB Sean Duggan from yellow to blue. In Nicholson's case it's because UNC, which looked so strong in this recruitment earlier, is starting to look like a really lousy place for a football player to spend the next four or five years of his life. In Duggan's case it's because Wisconsin dropped off the list. BC and Michigan are still gonna be tough to contend with, though.

- Moved LB Travis Hughes from red to yellow. I still don't think he'll end up here, but he seems serious. If he does, it'll be the greatest recruiting resurrection ever pulled at UVA.

- Moved QB Lafonte Thourogood from yellow to red. Starting to get the "it ain't happening" feeling.

******************************************

Newsy things:

- UNC's Kendric Burney is officially out for the UVA game, having lost his appeal. At the rate things are going, it doesn't look likely that most of the rest of their parked players will be on the field, either, though Deunta Williams is back this week. That's a very winnable game.

- The UNC game will be at 6 PM, online, no TV. Speaking as someone who's still working on ways to get recordings of online games: argh.

- Michael Phillips suggests that JKD is still listed as the DT starter mainly because he's a senior captain, and says that Matt Conrath is getting the first snaps. But, JKD was out there a lot on first downs against FSU. Unless Conrath was banged up - wouldn't have been evident either way from the ESPN3 broadcast - JKD is still getting the meaningful snaps.

- The lead guy at CavsCorner, Chris Wallace, mentioned that some numbnuts at the Atlanta Journal-Constitution asked this question of Mike London: "What changes have you made since taking over as head coach?" (I would have told him the only thing I did was paint the equipment shed, just to see what he prints.) This must be the guy:

Both Virginia and Groh have moved on. London, the first African-American coach in the history of Virginia athletics, has brought excitement to a program needing a boost.
Mr. Huff? Dave Leitao for you on line 1. It's no wonder the newspaper industry is slowly disappearing and practically every major newspaper in the country is, like the AJC, a hyphenated combination of two papers that would have failed on their own. I realize he's only one coach off, but this is a basic, fundamental statement of a plain fact that is plain wrong, and this man is somehow paid actual legal tender to do less research for his job than I do for my hobby, which is this blog that mucks around with an audience that is occasionally measured as low as the mere dozens. As opposed to the (theoretically) millions that get their information from his paper.

******************************************

High school senior seasons march on:

STAB 13, St. Christopher's 7: Thompson Brown's been having a really good season, but kept off the stat sheet here.

L.C. Bird 21, Monacan 13: Anthony Harris throws the go-ahead touchdown.

Hermitage 19, Deep Run 0: Diamonte Bailey assists in another Hermitage shutout.

Thomas Dale 12, Petersburg 8: Maybe a little rust as Kevin Green and Petersburg have had three straight weekends off.

>I.C. Norcom 45, Norview 0: Kameron Mack still rolling, and earning the shutout.

St. S/St. A 40, Randolph-Macon 0: Gotta like the shutouts our future defenders keep getting. This one belongs to Darius Lee.

Menchville 31, Gloucester 3: Clifton Richardson QBs his team to their first win of the season. Very nice to see. And he's homecoming king, too!

Phoebus 50, Woodside 10: #1-in-the-state Phoebus and Caleb Taylor crush a solid Woodside bunch.

Tallwood 14, Green Run 6: David Dean's team upset as Tallwood gets their first win of the year.

Cox 21, Princess Anne 17: Ross Burbank helps pave the way for a solid 200-plus yard night for Cox's running game.

Hampton 33, Warwick 0: Another easy one for David Watford.

Gonzaga 32, DeMatha 25: Upset loss for Kelby Johnson and Jordan Lomax. And UVA was recruiting that Gonzaga quarterback (Kevin Hogan) pretty heavily, too.

Damascus 35, Springbrook 14: Big win for Brandon Phelps against an undefeated team.

Stone Bridge 63, Marshall 7: Man....these teams never passed. Rob Burns in on the defensive shutdown but never got to rush the quarterback.

Good Counsel 48, Bishop McNamara 0: Vincent Croce pitches in on the shutout; prospect Blake Countess does a lot of the scoring.

Independence 51, Ardrey Kell 30: Adrian Gamble catches four passes for 125 yards.

Boys' Latin 45, St. Frances 0: Yep, another shutout. Marco Jones this time. SF is awful though.

Mt. Lebanon 35, Canon-McMillan 12: It's really hard to find your offensive linemen in the high school box scores, but at least Tim Cwalina keeps winning.

******************************************

I've decided to put the ongoing AP poll study in this section. I might give this its own page, but for this week this is what we're doing. Remember: these lag a week, so this is from last Sunday's poll. So here are this week's results. For explanation, please read here.



Trends that continue:

- If there's a team likely to be way overvoted, it's probably a big-name team. Less so this week, but man look at Texas. This is largely the result of voters either keeping them in the middle-ish of the poll after a hideous loss against UCLA, or kicking them out entirely.

- And if there's a group of writers most likely to hold a bias, it's probably West Coasters. Except....look what they did to Oregon. SEC voters ranked Oregon second, and Pac-10 voters had them damn near 7th. Very weird. Probably a one-time-only thing.

Regionalism continues to appear most strongly below the top 25, with conference-regional voters being the main driving force behind the appearance of teams like Northwestern, Oregon State, UCLA, and Missouri in the "also getting votes" section. Additionally, strong bias is evident from 21-25, with four of those five teams getting a huge boost from conference voters. Remember, at the bottom, higher differences in average ratings are harder to achieve, so the delta numbers for teams like NC State, Nevada, and MSU are significant.

However, overall, if you were trying to claim bias permeated this week's poll, you'd have only weak evidence to go on. Other than the almost omnipresent tendency of West Coast voters to overrate West Coast teams, everything else seems to be close to a random distribution again. Tune in next week, then.

Sunday, October 3, 2010

illusions

Reminiscing on upsets past and joyous times of yore has a way of clouding the in-between. With Florida State in town, talk was of 1995 and 2005, and that was fun. In between those two big wins, of course, I graduated junior high, high school, and college, and FSU visited Charlottesville four other times and handed our ass to us with parsley and tartar sauce. Hooray, another one for the pile.

Any illusion that the offense can be consistently functional againt a bowl-worthy defense should be shattered about now, and abandoned in the way that one day you realize you're not growing up to play baseball in the majors. In two games against defenses worth a damn, the offense has scored exactly two touchdowns when those defenses were actually trying, only one of which was the result of an actual drive. Florida State brainfarted on defense, and Marc Verica and Kris Burd smartly took advantage. After that, Verica's inner Interception Man appeared and finished what FSU started.

UVA did, by the way, almost nothing I thought they should do in the preview. Never to say that that stuff would have worked, but their way didn't, either. To wit:

- John-Kevin Dolce, all 250 pounds of him, was consistently on the field on running downs and consistently ended up 5 yards downfield before the running back was at the line of scrimmage. The man is at his best when given a step of space where he can use his athleticism, like on the pass rush - he doesn't otherwise have the beef for DT and the FSU running game took full advantage.

- Rather than punt at the sidelines, or rugby kick, or do something different than a straight up boom at the sky, UVA allowed Greg Reid to field everything he could get near. And FSU's field position benefitted beautifully from it.

- The FSU linebackers were allowed the luxury of keying on the run game, and they made every stop. There was very little play-action and tight end involvement to keep the linebackers busy and very few draw plays, too. Result: 2.9 yards per carry for the tailbacks.

Fact is, Florida State has more talent everywhere you look, at every single position on the field except for possibly cornerback, and this last is also hard to defend given the play of those backups. (More on that later.) That is probably one of the only really complete teams in the ACC.

On that note, the optimism: that is probably one of the only really complete teams in the ACC. Except for those that expected to hoist the crystal in January, there isn't a 2-2 team anywhere that thinks their season is over. Two more losses like that might change my perspective a little, but take a look at what Georgia Tech and UNC have accomplished this season and see if you don't think they're beatable. Watch that Duke-Maryland game again and see if you don't really like what you see. There's still plenty to look forward to this season, which is all you can ask for, really.

Stuff that didn't fit:

- My God, Devin Wallace had a really bad day. At least three, if not all four, of FSU's touchdowns can be more or less directly attributed to something he didn't do very well, be it tackle or cover. Wallace and Dom Joseph have been fairly solid in their careers, but neither of them would ever want to repeat their Saturday performances.

- It absolutely is not time to replace Marc Verica. I've always said his performance on the season shouldn't be judged until halfway through, and I'm sticking with that even if he throws five picks against GT. One, there are still bowl hopes, and not gumdrop rainbow ones either. Two, Metheny looked pretty good but FSU had their second string out and was hardly trying. And three, the people ready to throw Verica under the bus will probably be the same people ready to do the same to Metheny or Rocco in 2012 and '13. There's a certain breed of fan that just is never satisfied with what they're getting. They're rooting for the laundry, frankly. I happen to think that rooting for the team also means rooting for the players, and it's hard not to root for a guy who worked hard, gained the starting job, lost it, worked some more, got it back, and is looked to for leadership by the whole team.

I said it long before the season, repeatedly, and I'll say it again: that's a discussion we should have after the FSU-GT-UNC stretch, and only if we really look well out of bowl contention and Verica has been totally ineffective. If UVA wins just one of the next two, they'll be 3-3 going on 4-3. That'd be no time for a change at the helm.

- On the other hand, there are some depth chart changes that I'd either really like to see or wouldn't be surprised to. Like I said earlier, JKD should revert to his pass-rush role; he's getting blown up against the run. GT will exploit that mercilessly. And the O-line is hopefully still an evaluation in progress. I'd also like to replace the blank spots on the depth chart behind the two-deep at defensive back with actual scholarship players, but we can't have everything.

blogpoll ballot, week 5: the big 12 north revival edition

This week's ballot, presented for your consumption. Comments, as always, invited; I explain myself below.


As with last week, and every week hereafter, this is a resume ballot. Laddering - the practice of "Team X won so I should move them up X many spots" - is verboten, at least on my ballot. Moves up or down may be the result of winning or losing, yes, but they might also come from a change in perspective on the opponents.....

- For example, wins over BYU and Georgia are now officially given "whatever" status, much as if you had defeated Mississippi State or Wyoming, which explains why Arkansas and South Carolina bit it this week and Nevada took a bit of a drop.

Actually, Mississippi State is, for now, considered a better win than Georgia.

- Holy crap, I crunched the numbers this week and Michigan came up 6th. Ahead of Ohio State, even. Weird, and my first thought was to do a little divine intervention there, as is often done after the numbers churn out whatever they churn out, but I had another thought. Yeah, Michigan's had some narrow scrapes against what "should" be inferior opposition, like UMass, but then again, UMass is 4-1 and 8th-ranked in I-AA and would probably have a winning record against OSU's opponents, who are 8-15 total. Not having a good day against Illinois didn't help the Buckeyes either, so that basically answers any Indiana-related concerns you'd have about Michigan.

No, I'm not moving Boise State ahead, either, at least not until VT digs themselves further out of their hole.

Thursday, September 30, 2010

game preview: Florida State

Date/Time: Saturday, October 2; 12:00

TV: ACC Network (formerly Raycom)/ESPN3 for those of us blacked out

History against the Seminoles: 2-13

Last matchup: FSU 33, UVA 0 - game vacated by FSU

Last week: UVA 48, VMI 7; FSU 31, WF 0

Line: Florida State by 7

Opposing blogs: Tomahawk Nation, Scalp 'Em

Injury report:

OUT

TE Jeremy Dollin
WR Bobby Smith
WR Tim Smith
WR Eric Thornton

DOUBTFUL - none

QUESTIONABLE - none

PROBABLE

OT Landon Bradley
WR Kris Burd
RB Raynard Horne
S Corey Mosley
S Brian Oden
LB LaRoy Reynolds
TE Joe Torchia

Uniform combination: blue jersey, white pants

Other useful stuff:
Q&A with Tomahawk Nation
Other half of the Q&A
FSU season preview

Things looked a lot different last time we saw this. Two old dudes roamed the sidelines in Bobby Bowden and Al Groh, and FSU was ranked in the top 5. In fact, the last time FSU came to Charlottesville not ranked in the top ten is probably never. Now Groh is gone, and so is Bowden (significantly decreasing FSU's dislikability factor), and for the first time, UVA fans aren't looking to next week's game with this one already written off as a loss.

There's also a lot of looking back, of course. "Florida State at Virginia" brings back pleasant memories of two of UVA's best upsets since the Welsh era began - heck, maybe the two best ever. It's a disappointing side effect of the expanded ACC that the opportunity to really relive 1995 and 2005 will now come up just once every five years, but that's the way it is. In 1995 I hadn't yet added orange to my maize-and-blue loyalties, but I do have pretty strong and exciting memories of an autumn evening in 2005 - which you would admit is impressive if you'd seen the roughly gallon-and-a-half of beer I'd imbibed through the afternoon. The date has special significance for UVA fans and Michigan fans alike, so combined with the Boston bar-hopping it's been the football Saturday by which all other football Saturdays are judged in my book. Can similar memories be made on Saturday?

HOW WE CAN WIN

- Christian Ponder isn't much of a deep thrower. His triceps are probably better than they were, but they're still not 100% and I still don't expect a lot of big bomb-type throws. Roughly 10 yards per completion against Wake - that's a fairly low number. Combine Ponder's wonky triceps with the likely absence of LT Andrew Datko, and FSU's likeliest course of action in the passing game is quick slants and dinking and dunking their way down the field. That means plenty of throws to possession receiver extraordinaire Bert Reed, Ponder's favorite target. Reed will probably match up with Chase Minnifield, but what I'd really like to see is Minnifield on Taiwan Easterling and the comparatively monstrous Ras-I Dowling on Reed. (Reed is teensy.) If Dowling has regained his quicks, he can use his size to limit Reed. I think Minnifield can hang with Easterling. Additionally, we'll need outstanding side-to-side play from our linebackers.

- Because of the short passing game, I don't expect the pass rush to be a huge factor unless the cornerbacks are really doing a good job on the FSU receivers. So more run-stopping beef on the D-line - that is, more playing time for Matt Conrath and Nick Jenkins over John-Kevin Dolce, except in obvious passing downs - should be of greater help against the very efficient FSU running game.

- Is there a weakness in the FSU defense? The only team yet to find one is Oklahoma, which doesn't have a monster running game but did shred FSU through the air. Nobody's really run successfully on FSU this year, and my thought is UVA will need heavy doses of the pass to keep the run defense honest. Getting the tight ends open will be key. FSU has very, very good linebackers, but they can't step up for run defense if they're in pass coverage against our tight ends. A successful offensive attack might start with a few strikes to TE's Torchia and Phillips, and draw plays when Lazor wants to run the ball.

HOW WE CAN LOSE

- The worst thing that can happen is for FSU to be able to establish their running game. Not unlike Payne and Jones, FSU has a quality tandem of big-and-small running backs. Level of competition obviously has to be taken into account when considering the impressive run-game results, but the only team to date to stop FSU has been Oklahoma, and, you know, we're not Oklahoma.

- Under no circumstances whatsoever should Greg Reid be allowed to field a punt.

- Remember how, before the season, every preview of the offense written anywhere began with "if the offensive line...."? This is why. USC aside (and UVA wasn't especially effective on offense there), this is really the kind of game that that phrase was meant for. FSU will just bulldoze the offense if they're allowed to and it'll be the kind of long, frustrating afternoon that ends up with a score of 34-6 if the O-line doesn't give the skill players room to work. Their defense is more than good enough to just shut us right down.

HOW THE GAME WILL GO

Really, it'll hinge on the two O-lines. And Ponder. UVA's is healthy but still of questionable ability - we don't really know yet if they're a good, ACC-caliber unit or not. FSU's is not healthy and in a little bit of flux: Datko, their top tackle, is out, and Zebrie Sanders may or may not move to left tackle for the game.

Ponder, meanwhile, is a bigger mystery than Verica. FSU pushed him as a major-league Heisman candidate, but that was borderline silly. Ponder isn't a Heisman-caliber quarterback. But he does have the ability to drive the offense down the field and hurt you. He also has the capacity to miss receivers he should hit. Verica's a wild-card in a different fashion - you know the giant brainfart is coming, you just don't know when and you hope it doesn't hurt you too bad. But otherwise Verica is Verica and you know what you're getting. Sometimes with Ponder, the whole game is a lost cause, though that sort of thing is getting less frequent as he gets older.

Really, FSU should win this game. There's still a talent gap. But even though both teams are under new management, there's a difference in the change. As FSU fans will point out, the team is being coached again. Bobby Bowden, the thinking goes, didn't do much of that. Fisher's introducing plays and schemes and stuff, and the thought process no longer stops at the assumption that being Florida State is enough to make them bigger better faster and that's all it takes. Contrast that to the change here at UVA, where the problem was not undercoaching, but overscheming. The schemes of Mike London, Bill Lazor, and Jim Reid are still schemes and they're still coaching, but they demand much less thought, much less "if A then B" going on inside a player's head while the play goes on around him. Makes playing easier. For this reason, you will see UVA overachieve relative to expectations, while FSU has ups and downs, good games and bad, and may or may not play up to their talent level while they get used to being coached again.

And don't forget the overlook aspect: FSU has Miami next week. We're just little ol' Virginia. You always beat us. No need to get too excited.

So I'd be surprised to see a blowout. UVA may still lose - in fact, I think the chances of that are better than even. But since we've been reminiscing about FSU's past trips to Charlottesville, let's talk about 2003. The Hoos lost, 19-14, playing a very solid game (particularly on defense) but were done in by one really glaring, ugly weakness and a couple ill-timed mistakes. In that team's case, the weakness was punting and the worst mistake was a poor snap that ruined a crucial third down. This seems like the kind of game we're in for. Fortunately, nothing on this team is as bad as the punting was in that game, although there's no Matt Schaub or Ahmad Brooks, either. But - eliminate the mistake(s), and what happens instead? A Virginia win may be the answer. It'll be close enough that we might just get to find out.

REST OF THE ACC

Miami @ Clemson, 12:00
Virginia Tech @ NC State, 3:30
North Carolina vs. East Carolina, 3:30
Duke @ Maryland, 6:00
Georgia Tech @ Wake Forest, 7:00
Boston College vs. Notre Dame, 8:00

Wednesday, September 29, 2010

Q&A with Tomahawk Nation

It's finally ACC season, and to celebrate, here we have Bud of Tomahawk Nation to answer some questions about Florida State in preparation for the upcoming home game against the Seminoles. Florida State in Scott Stadium brings back some terrific memories (and some forgettable blowouts), but sadly thanks to the expanded schedule, that's an event less common than presidential elections.

The format is the usual; here are my questions and Bud's answers. A little bit of enlightenment to reacquaint everyone with FSU football. When it's up, I'll link the other half of the conversation. And here it is. Go read - the other half of these Q&As are always a great way to see what the other side thinks is important about UVA, and what I think about that.

1. Which is the real Christian Ponder - the Oklahoma version or the Wake Forest version? Which should we expect to see in Charlottesville?

The real Christian Ponder is hard to figure out right now. Clearly he is banged up with the triceps bruise that swells up sometimes. He wears a compression sleeve 24/7. Against Oklahoma the issues were with Ponder, the receivers, and the line. Even banged up, he's one of the better ACC QBs. I'd expect to see safe throws except off play-action. Ponder is still smart and quick through his reads.

2. How is the Jimbo Fisher era so far? Are FSU fans giving him as much of a chance as any new coach or do you see him having the kind of difficulties that usually seem to come with following a legend?

I don't think he's having the "following a legend" difficulties because Bowden left FSU in shambles. FSU has a 16-16 conference record over the last 4 years.... after losing 20 games in the last 4 years... after having the 7th worst major-conference defense... after not even winning its own division in the ACC in the last 4. Add all the stuff with hiring his unqualified or washed-up buddies to coach and the stuff with his son and the recent version of Bowden isn't much of a legend to follow.

Fisher is going through growing pains in terms or learning how to delegate and trusting others, particularly the media. On-field stuff has been sharp though, including clock management.

3. What's the biggest difference between Bowden's Seminoles and Fisher's Seminoles, besides fewer "dadgums" at press conferences?

Fisher is Saban-lite. The obsessive attention to detail and focus on "process over results." He's never satisfied and the team reflects that. The improved weight program (FSU's defensive linemen averaged more than 15 lbs of added muscle this off-season!) has also been a huge change. FSU is turning into an SEC-like team in terms of the way it looks physically, which is what Fisher wants. He's also changed practice routines to more than double the reps and has added a ton of new staffers to make sure no stone goes unturned.

4. Is E.J. Manuel a change-of-pace QB or have his appearances been mainly the result of the four blowouts FSU's been involved in?

Manuel is not a change-of-pace guy. He's decidedly the backup, though Fisher loves him. Manuel is Jimbo's prized recruit (from Virginia Beach) and Fisher has worked to change his delivery from the mess it was in 2008. He's come in during blow-outs and against Oklahoma because Christian was really rattled and hurting, but I don't expect to see him this weekend. UVA fans will get to see him next year in Tally for sure.

5. Would you trade a loss in this game if it meant you could guarantee a win next week at Miami?

No, I would not. I thought about this, and while the win in Miami helps recruiting, I think FSU has probably a 12% chance to lose both, a 32% to win both, a 48% chance to beat UVA and lose at UM, and an 8% chance to lose to UVA while beating Miami. Sorry for the gambling math there, but what I am trying to say is that FSU would be throwing more away than it gained. Plus, Virginia is still seen as a bad team after the last two years and the loss would be embarrassing to FSU fans, though I know UVA is better.

(Ed.: the math here means Bud figures an 80% chance of beating UVA and a 40% chance of beating Miami. With any luck, the reality will be the opposite.)

****************************************

As always, thanks to Tomahawk Nation for their half. Check back tomorrow for the game preview!

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

the recruit: Kevin Green

Name: Kevin Green
Position: ???
Hometown: Petersburg
School: Petersburg
Height: 6'3"
Weight: 195

ESPN: none
Rivals: none
Scout: two stars, #76 QB

Other offers: none

Talk about your mystery recruits. Here we have a guy with no other offers, no evaluations, and no future position. Green didn't really even have a recruiting story, at least not a public one - he's a legacy since his father, Kevin Morgan, played at UVA, and Green wanted to follow in his footsteps. Offer, commitment - done.

Green plays quarterback and linebacker for Petersburg, and on offense he really racks up the yards as a dual-threat guy. Almost 5,000 of them last season, and 39 touchdowns, both passing (24) and running (15.) Six more touchdowns this season in just two games. Suffice it to say, Green is the kind of quarterback, operating in a quarterback's offense, that will be putting up gaudy stats basically every week.

The thing is that Green almost certainly won't be playing quarterback at UVA. With David Watford onboard for that job and plenty of freshmen on the roster, Green would be buried. He was offered "as a football player" and I doubt the coaches even know where he'll end up just yet, or even which side of the ball.

For reasons of both program depth and Green's size, the likeliest candidates are WR, LB, or safety. He'd be tall for a safety, which kind of rules out cornerback. He's light for a linebacker, and the coaches will have to decide whether he's going to bulk up to at least 225 or not. ESPN lists him at 205, so who knows? He's about the perfect size for a receiver, and clearly has the athleticism, but wide receiver is where the coaches are recruiting quite a few players at the moment so I don't think they see Green as one.

So defense is where he'll probably be, and LB or S depending on whether he bulks up or not. Me, I'd prefer safety. Assuming he redshirts, his redshirt freshman year will be a year after Rodney McLeod, Corey Mosley, and Dom Joseph all graduate, leaving zilch at their position except for Green's classmates, and we have absolutely no idea whether or not Kyrrel Latimer will even make it in or Javanti Sparrow will make it back. I have absolutely no way of projecting how well Green will do, given that literally the only data on him is at a position he'll never play. But if indeed he's a future safety, early playing time seems like a rock-solid guarantee.

Monday, September 27, 2010

weekend review

Hooray for a weekend with football in it. They say there was football last weekend too. Could've fooled me, I didn't see any UVA games so it couldn't have been much. This weekend, some stuff happened and some other stuff too, so here we go.....

Recruiting board gets a small update with:

- DE Horace Arkadie added to yellow.

- WR Demetri Knowles moved from yellow to blue.

Dominique Wallace's departure leaves another scholarship opening and the small possibility UVA goes harder after another running back, like Nyjee Fleming. But I don't see that happening. Too many priority targets and frankly, not enough space. There are 18 openings for next year, by my count, but don't forget that Javanti Sparrow could well return.

Then again, the coaches seem to think they need fifty defensive ends. Maybe Arkadie is being recruited as a linebacker. He's in the yellow section despite putting UVA in a top two or three because I can't imagine he's being recruited especially hard. I'd be pretty content if the coaches shut down recruiting except for about ten priority targets, even if they only landed one.

*******************************************

News items!

Two from the department via the Sabre message board: one, Tim Smith is out for the year. If you'd told me on September 1 that Smith would be out with ankle surgery before October 1, my reaction would have been pretty R-rated. But Burd and Inman have been plenty productive and my initial reaction is that if that keeps up, there's no big loss in having Smith redshirt this year (he's very likely to receive a medical redshirt) and get an extra campaign out of him. I just hope that's not fool's gold given the quality of the competition. Regardless of whether it's a big loss or not, the surgery sounds like the right decision - a 60% Tim Smith isn't really any better than Jared Green.

Mike London tends to announce the weekend's uniform combo on his radio show, and blue-over-white is the call for this week. Which is good, I was worried that the so-called white-out would also mean white jerseys, which should never be worn at home I'm looking at you Georgia Tech.

Speaking of the white-out, with the game at noon on Raycom, I bet the athletic department regrets the decision to announce that particular promotion before the TV lineups were announced. Their recent promotions have been by and large a whopping success - the Building of a Program show and the ODU scrimmage were both huge hits - and it's starting to feel like the program is taking the shoot-first-ask-questions-later approach to promotions. Time to slow down here - now that they've wasted a big white-out deal on a noon game with a backwater network, something similar like an orange-out for a later game like Miami would start to feel contrived and stale.

*******************************************

Checking in on the high schools:

Hermitage 17, Varina 12 - Varina's defense scored all 12 points; Diamonte Bailey and Hermitage pitched their offense a shutout and held them to 91 yards.

L.C. Bird 29, Thomas Dale 3 - Anthony Harris doin' it all: two touchdown throws and one more on the run, as well as an interception.

St. Christopher's 35, Norfolk Academy 0 - Thompson Brown in the news with 11 tackles in a shutout, and scored a touchdown too.

I.C. Norcom 47, Woodrow Wilson 7 - Kameron Mack's team rolls again.

Green Run 34, Salem 14 - Big win to get the season on track for David Dean.

Landstown 28, Cox 7 - Loss for Ross Burbank.

Kecoughtan 57, Menchville 6 - Menchville: not a good team. This is as good a time as any to point out that much respect came Clifton Richardson's way for not transferring.

Hampton 49, Denbigh 12 - David Watford has it easy most nights.

Glen Mills 33, H.D. Woodson 18 - Darius Redman held off the score sheet as Woodson loses an 18-0 halftime lead on their trip to Pennsylvania.

Stone Bridge 49, Thomas Jefferson 0 - Rob Burns helps hold Jefferson to 13 total yards of offense. You read that right.

Good Counsel 53, Bishop O'Connell 7 - Another shutout for our defenders, this time Vincent Croce. O'Connell scored on a kickoff return.

DeMatha 41, Paul VI 6 - Jordan Lomax blocks a punt.

Bishop Ireton 49, St. Stephen's/St. Agnes 13 - Yeowch for Darius Lee.

Damascus 22, Seneca Valley 16 - Dogfight for Brandon Phelps, but remains undefeated.

Independence 49, East Mecklenburg 6 - Adrian Gamble gets his first win of the year.

Boys' Latin 16, St. John's 12 - Squeaker for Marco Jones. Speaking of whom, here's some reading for you, interview-style.

Mt. Lebanon 28, Hopewell 20 - Got moved thanks to a power outage, but it didn't matter for Tim Cwalina's team.

*******************************************

And the rest of the ACC?

VT 19, BC 0:

Dave Shinskie's play was "a special kind of horrible" and BC Interruption asks if we've seen the last of him, as BC will be making a quarterback change for next week. Shocking. And it says something really scary about BC's quarterback situation that Frank Spaziani claims it'll be a gametime decision. It's a bad enough sign when you can't figure out who your quarterback is all throughout training camp - if you're still holding competitions four weeks into the season, you truly have no quarterback and might as well toss a coin to see who gets the privilege of starting his college career by going 9 for 19 with three picks.

NC State 45, GT 28:

Winfield at From The Rumble Seat is trying to remain calm:


I don't post anything on Sundays because I am working on this year being more objective in my thoughts with a little less emotion. Rants and raves feel good (a little) but they don't get you anywhere.
Can't blame him, but wait til November, my friend. What good is writing a blog if you refuse to use it as a soapbox to call for the firing of everyone involved with the latest fiasco?

Maryland 42, FIU 28:

Danny O'Brien is starting to make a name for himself in College Park, brewing a bit of a quarterback controversy, and Testudo Times has no faith at all in the Fridge to manage it correctly.

*******************************************

That's it for the weekend. If we're lucky this week, a little Q&A session looms to celebrate the first ACC game of the year.

regional bias study, second week

If you haven't seen last week's look at the AP poll to study it for regional bias, check that out, to get up to speed and for instructions on reading the charts. Here are this week's:



Chart 1 displays what I referred to as "overvotes" - that is, the number of times a team was ranked in a ballot five places or more than their actual poll ranking. Chart 2 displays the averages. Keep in mind, these are the votes from the poll that came out on September 21, not yesterday.

Some trends from last week continue.

- Marquee teams like Oklahoma, Florida, USC, and Michigan are far more likely to get overvotes than non-name teams.
- Pac-10-area voters are generally more guilty than most of overrating teams from their own region, though not quite as strongly as last week.
- The strongest evidence of regional bias continues to be located in the area of the poll below the top 25 where the simple act of voting for a team at all constitutes overrating them. The four teams ranked from 30th-33rd - Fresno State, Missouri, Oklahoma State, and Clemson - get the lion's share of their votes from their home regions. Particularly Fresno State - good lord the West Coast voters are shameless in their support for the Bulldogs. However, in the top 25 itself, there appears to be little evidence outside the West Coast (and even that is rather weak) that regional bias is manifest.

One trend that disappeared this week was the one-vote teams: last week, the vast majority of them received their lone vote from regional voters. This week that isn't the case.

The averages chart is very interesting, though. Had those numbers shown up last week it would have really perked my ears up for regional biases. Last week the distribution looked about 100% random. This week there's some noticeable upvoting for regional teams. The average "bias" is to rank teams a third of a place higher than the rest of the country - a small number to be sure, but there are just eight teams out of 25 that didn't receive favorable reviews from their home region writers. It'll be interesting to see, going forward, whether last week's trend (basically zero bias in the top 25) or this week's holds true.