Sunday, October 17, 2010

blogpoll ballot, week 7


The machine broke this week and spit out some pretty weird results, so I had to apply some common sense. Even with common sense applied, it's one of those weeks where I'd rather just rank 20 and call it a day. But the teams that didn't make the cut are just really weak. Texas, Arkansas, Nevada, USC, Miami - well, Nevada's WAC-snack schedule looks pretty bad when you start losing to it. And I remain relatively unimpressed with Nebraska as compared to everyone else, which means that beating them is also less exciting. But at least the Horns are back in the conversation.

Other things which might look weird to discerning eyes:

- NC State lost at a very inconvenient time, but VT's rise gives them a boost. Plus, GT is a very solid win and UCF is actually looking like a better opponent than it used to. But mainly, I looked at the teams just outside the top 25 and none of them really jumped out.

- Michigan isn't going to be a popular pick to be ranked, but they did only ever lose to top-10 teams. I'm probably still overrating Indiana and therefore the value of beating them, but whatever.

- Arizona is way the hell below Iowa, which would be weird if Arizona hadn't spent the last few weeks looking horribly unimpressive. 10-9 over Cal? 24-7 over a 1-6 WSU team? (Possibly the most competitive 1-6 team out there, but still.)

- Mississippi State sure took a flying leap up the rankings, which surprised the hell out of me, but I'm OK with it for now. They've been competitive in their two losses to the #1 and #2 teams on the ballot, and they deserve a reward for knocking off Florida and Georgia. I think they'll drop sooner or later, but for now, why not?

- Oklahoma got hurt a bit by having a bye week - the system is a little biased against teams with byes and in favor of those who've played a full schedule. I'm OK with that, though, because isn't 7-0 better than 6-0?

Anyway, this is still not a ballot I'm totally onboard with, so a little corrective input is always welcome.

Saturday, October 16, 2010

you have to give al groh this

His defenses at least waited til the second half to fall to shit.

Yeah, normally I write this column on Sunday after I'm done with my Blogpoll ballot, but I don't have anything better to do right now, and why waste a perfectly good foul mood? This was supposed to be the most winnable of the three test games that just occurred, and instead it turns out to be Free Football Night at Scott Stadium. Wear your Carolina blue and white and get a complimentary souvenir courtesy of our friendly quarterback crew!

Or maybe I'm being too harsh. Here, let me try the rational, objective approach. Let's list some positives and negatives from the game. Surely we can find something to talk about.

Positives:

- The new, more metallic blue helmets look really sharp during night games under the lights.

Negatives:

- The defense.
- The offense, other than Keith Payne.
- The special teams.
- The coaching, probably.
- Orange-on-orange uniform combo.
- The defense.

Well, that's quite a list. Let's tackle that one-by-one.

- First off, the players are fired from uniform selection duties, or they should be until they win. For the EMU game, simple old-fashioned blue-over-white. Need to remove distractions. And that's too bad, 'cause I'd really like to see the orange-over-white. But teams that lose by 34 don't need either the distraction or the privilege of frivolities like fashion design.

- Actually, the special teams weren't really a negative - not that they got much of a chance to flash their stuff. Except the kick return squad. Lot of field time, there. I should add that if we ever allow him to do his thing, instead of opting for the direct QB-to-defender method of transferring possession, that Jimmy Howell is really an excellent punter these days.

- I'll let the coaches' honeymoon last a little while longer, if they promise to do some tackling drills and never again call four straight Keith Payne runs up the gut that result in a turnover on downs. Like the whole state couldn't see that one coming. Ross Metheny was in at the time - if you're evaluating freshmen quarterbacks, anything other than an off-tackle handoff would be a good way to do it.

- The running game was actually not horrible. In fact it was perfectly functional, and had there been any kind of support from any other facet of the team, we'd be heaping praise upon Keith Payne for his effort tonight. As it is all he gets is to stop running gassers early.

Besides the obvious issues under center, I'll give one other player who had a very rough game and needs a lot of work: Morgan Moses. Big Mo moved side to side like he was standing in wet cement. I think I'd rather see him understudy at guard behind B.J. Cabbell (who played reasonably well and was the prime mover in opening that massive hole for Payne on Payne's touchdown) where he can be more of a mauler. I don't think a man that size is ever going to move side-to-side too well; at guard he won't have to, and he could probably be a holy terror when pulling to the other side.

- Alright. The defense. As if it wasn't obvious against Florida State, the "offense needs to stay on the field longer to rest the defense" excuse is as acceptable as a $3 bill anymore. When you're down 7-0 after the very first play from scrimmage, it's time to give that idea a rest. Now the defense is just bad.

And frankly, it's baffling. This is supposed to be an easier defense to learn, which means that the growing pains into a new system should be minimized. The linebackers are regressing, which I suppose you can chalk up to the fact that most of them are playing a new position in a new system. But why is the secondary so horrible? The responsibilities aren't that different, and that's supposedly the veteran core of the defense. It's officially time to worry about Devin Wallace - he got burned nice and toasty all night. The quarterback issue is frustrating but explainable. The defense is frustrating and completely baffling, which is a lot worse.

So what about the rest of the season? In order to get bowl-eligible, we'd have to beat one of either Miami or VT plus everyone else on the schedule. So that's the last time this year you'll see the word "bowl" around here. If next week is not a win, you might as well empty the bench; Eastern Michigan is one of the absolute worst teams in all of I-A football. Worse than Richmond. After that, I see two chances to put another number in the win column: Duke and Maryland. To take any measure of success at all from this season, both are must-wins. I shouldn't have to explain why.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

game preview: North Carolina

Date/Time: October 16; 6:00 PM

TV: ESPN3

History against the Heels: 54-56-4

Last matchup: UVA 16, UNC 3; 10/3/09 in Chapel Hill

Last week: GT 33, UVA 21; UNC 21, Clemson 16

Line: UNC by 6.5

Opposing blogs: Carolina March, Tar Heel Fan

Also see, because I needed somewhere to put this: FTRS's roundtable roundup

Uniform combination: orange jersey, orange pants (dammit)

Injury report:

OUT

LT Landon Bradley
WR Tim Smith (season)
TE Joe Torchia (season)

DOUBTFUL - none

QUESTIONABLE

DE Billy Schautz
WR Dontrelle Inman

PROBABLE

WR Kris Burd
CB Ras-I Dowling
FB Terence Fells-Danzer
WR Bobby Smith
LB Ausar Walcott

UNC season preview, take it FWIW since it was written before their roster was nuked

With UNC, there's always something. Besides the streak which I'm not even going to talk about, somehow this game always has some kind of back story. Once upon a time it was Ronald Curry; these days it's the personal rain cloud that UNC carries with it in the form of an NCAA doomhammer that's likely to be both heavier and swifter than that laid on USC.

Plus, the game is usually at some point in the season that's relatively pivotal. Just so this year as well. A loss here ends any hopes for a bowl game, unless we can get an upset win over Miami or VT. So a loss here ends any hopes for a bowl game. But a win would be a real springboard of optimism, because next week is Eastern Michigan, which would mean a win streak and a winning record headed into Miami. It might be unfounded optimism, but it'd be two solid weeks of optimism nonetheless.

It also might be a must-win if you ever want to see UVA on TV again this year. The notion that UVA is one of the conference's worst teams and an automatic win for everyone on the schedule but Duke wasn't dispelled by the USC game, and certainly not by the GT and FSU games either. Relegation to ESPN3 for all eternity (or at least all of 2010 as well as the beginning of 2011) is part of what's at stake here.

HOW WE CAN WIN

- Man up. UNC doesn't have any wrinkles. They don't have a crazy offense like GT, or a deceptively mobile quarterback like FSU. The crowd will be favorable. And the UNC playcalling in last year's game made Wisconsin look like Oregon. Sometimes football is as simple as beating the guy across from you; that's the way it goes here. The best way to win a game like this is to win all the matchups. That's what happened last year.

- Establish the run game and control the clock. The notion that winning the time of possession battle also wins you the football game has been exposed as a fraud and everyone knows it but the "experts." It's because they keep seeing this matchup in their minds. Here, it matters; the defense should be able to keep UNC's punt team busy more often than not, if they don't get worn down by constant failure by their own offense. Both teams have excellent pass defense; establish the run game better than thy opponent and verily thou shalt find victory - that is the commandment for the game. It'll also keep Verica from committing inconvenient turnovers.

HOW WE CAN LOSE

- Keep tackling like we've been tackling. Shaun Draughn and Johnny White, and especially the newly eligible Ryan Houston, aren't little guys. They'll have no problem getting major yards after contact and turning five yards into fifty if the tackling doesn't improve.

- Let Jheranie Boyd get loose. I don't think UNC's passing game is all that frightening - it's largely an extension of their running game with the two leading receivers being White and tight end Zack Pianalto. Not a bad player, Pianalto, an all-ACC pick for sure, but losing Greg Little had a major effect on the UNC passing game. Boyd is the only downfield threat, but he's a big one. Very fast. Got a 97-yard touchdown to his name this year. This'll be a tight game, and if UVA hopes to win, big plays and lightning strikes can't be part of the UNC arsenal.

- Underestimate this defense. It might be easy to, what with half of it lost in the NCAA tornado. It'd be a big mistake. This is still a competitive defense - in fact, it might well be said UNC hasn't lost a step so far. The games they've lost, they could easily have lost anyway. If ever Bill Lazor or his offensive line or his quarterback start to think this could be an easier ride than they'd expected, it'll be a long afternoon.

HOW THE GAME WILL GO

There's no reason to expect that this game will be any different than the last three: close, low-scoring affairs involving extended field position battles. Making it even hairier for the fans is that neither team wants to involve their field goal kickers. The good news for Heel fans is that the impending sanctions may have given Butch Davis the ammo he needs to overcome his rep as a recruiter who can't get the best out of his talent. UNC has been playing with a fire in their gut, kindled by the us-against-the-world mentality that's so easy to instill in college kids these days. Hell, Davis has even backed off on the noises he was making about playing Bryn Renner; Renner has attempted one pass all season and T.J. Yates is the no-doubt starter, averting a quarterback controversy.

With UNC playing so solidly and UVA being considered an ACC bottom-feeder, the outside world surely has this one chalked up in the UNC column already. So maybe it's a sign of my homerism that I refuse to make a prediction here. Too close to call. It's early enough in the season that I still think UVA is capable of what it needs to do in order to beat North Carolina. That's hardly where you want to be to be confident of protecting a streak which I'm not even going to talk about, but it's your sign that we still have a season.

REST OF THE ACC

NC State @ East Carolina, 12:00
Boston College @ Florida State, 12:00
Maryland @ Clemson, 12:00
Miami @ Duke, 1:00
Wake Forest @ Virginia Tech, 3:30
Georgia Tech vs. Middle Tennessee, 3:30

Wednesday, October 13, 2010

ACC roundtable: midseason


Time for another edition of the ACC Roundtable, the #1 gathering of college football blogs anywhere. Your host this week is From The Rumble Seat, which works out even better than usual because FTRS has four writers and therefore a case of multiple personality disorder. They can answer their own questions and yet be surprised at the answers. And speaking of answers....

1. Half the regular season is now kaput. Has your team exceeded, met, or fell short of your preseason predictions?

Met, I guess. Really, 2-3 shouldn't surprise anyone. Early games exceeded expectations, causing them to be raised a bit too high for the following ones. Honestly, if you'd have told me in August UVA'd be 2-3 after five games, I'd have said, "Well, duh."

2. The ACC finished the first half of the season 23-14 in out-of-conference play. If we took out the I-AA games, that'd be a lowly 12-13 record. If we took out the non-BCS squads, that'd be a 3-10 record against BCS opponents. If we further removed the Big East, we'd have ZERO wins in out of conference play and 9 losses against the SEC, Big 10, Pac 10, and Big 12... There are nine more out-of-conference games for the ACC including 6 games against BCS opponents. Is there any hope for rehabilitating the ACC's tarnished image?

Wait til bowl season. People have a way of attaching too much weight to the results of a single bowl season. A few favorable matchups there and the ACC's faceplant against good competition will be forgotten.

3. The Atlantic and Coastal divisions are knotted up at 5 wins apiece in interdivision play. Which division is better top to bottom?

At the bottom, the Atlantic is clearly better. Wake and Maryland both beat Duke, which establishes Duke as the worst team in the conference to date. Florida State looks like the best team so far, what with that housing of Miami last week. So the Atlantic is best top and bottom, but I don't think it's the best top to bottom. Pick two reasonable choices for #1 and #6 in each division, and I'll take the Coastal's #2 through #5 over the Atlantic.

4. Who is the ACC's first half of the season offensive MVP? Defensive MVP? Any comeback player of the year nominees or predictions for ACC Rookie of the Year?

I'm actually more impressed by Chris Thompson's 9-odd yards per carry, leading FSU in yardage despite being third in carries, than with the obvious choice of Russell Wilson and his 17 touchdowns. But MVP means "most valuable," not "best." NC State has surrounded Wilson with a cast of questionable talent, so their unexpectedly impressive start is all Russell. He's the choice.

On the other hand, NC State might be doing even better if not for Jayron Hosley of VT. Hosley's interceptions have paved the path of salvation for the Hokies after their loss to James Madison, which I don't know if you heard about that but the Hokies lost to James Madison. Hosley is your defensive MVP so far, edging out BC's Luke Kuechly and his 71 (!) tackles so far.

As for comeback player of the year, yes I'm going the homer route. I'm contractually obligated to at some point. Keith Payne spent three and a half years slipping further and further into Al Groh's doghouse, mostly through his own fault. Then he left it through the back door, quitting the team early in 2009. When Mike London was hired, Payne wanted back, and jumped through every hoop required of him. Who's your ACC touchdown leader? Keith Payne.

5. What games are still circled on the schedule as must win games for your fan base and program?

I'm choking on the very words, but VT isn't an attainable goal just yet. During a rebuilding project you've got to see forward progress, and you've got to get the easy ones under your belt. That means EMU and Duke at a minimum. Maryland will be seen as winnable and nobody wants to lose that one at home. And it's hard to say whether or not UNC is out of reach at the moment, but there's a streak to protect.

6. Let's say your university invented a device capable of transporting one individual from your program's past. And then the machine would collapse into itself due to the sheer greatness of said individual. What one player from your long and storied history would you cherrypick to instantly upgrade your team?

This team is in desperate need of an offensive line. I'd go get a scrambling quarterback like Aaron Brooks or Marques Hagans to alleviate some of the problems caused by the fact that Marc Verica's pocket sense is lousy, but instead I think we'll get a bulldozing tackle who could block for both the pass and the run reasonably well - that'd be top-five NFL pick D'Brickashaw Ferguson - and then, because that's just one lineman out of five, I'll borrow another important piece of scientific progress.....


Boink.

7. Now that you've seen ~29% of the scheduled ACC games, who will be in the 2010 ACC Championship Game?

Florida State and Virginia Tech, because that is what will piss me off the most.

Tuesday, October 12, 2010

weekend review

Much to see, much to do. The weekend review plows ahead with....

....recruiting board update. Here's what's new:

- Removed LB Conner Crowell, who's down to OSU and PSU. Pick Penn State.

- Moved CB Blake Countess from yellow to red. Looking highly unlikely.

- Moved LB Curtis Grant from blue to red. Ditto. Also, dammit.

- Added S Avery Walls to red.

- Created a new green section. I kept seeing players in blue and yellow that didn't quite feel like they belonged there, exactly, and I kept thinking "if only I had an in between section that's where they'd be." And then I realized I had the power to do that because it's my blog. The new residents of the area just in between blue and yellow are DE Horace Arkadie and LB D.J. Hill (up from yellow) and LB Sean Duggan and CB Demetrious Nicholson (down from blue.)

Pessimism is the name of the game this week in recruiting. It has been two months since the last commitment, after all. But in a way that's by design: the staff has to be careful with who they take. There's probably only a small list of maybe six or seven players they'd take a commitment from right this minute - guys like Demetrious Nicholson and Travis Hughes - and they're all being patient with the process. You see the five players in bold orange - as you'll remember they're my own choices as most-desired names. Just below those five would be Sean Duggan and Rory Anderson. Of those seven, I would bet a lot of money on UVA getting at least one, and I doubt they get more than three. Three would be about the awesomest thing ever, really. (Remember, names in red don't get bolded in orange because red is while-we're-at-it-I-want-a-pony land.)

*******************************************

....depth chart update. I did something new here too. Names in red are guys who are out for the season, and names in purple are guys who are out but not all year. They remain bolded and/or italicized so you have an idea of their role if healthy and what the team would look like without injuries getting in the way.

Changes are:

- Joe Torchia is out for the year, so Colter Phillips is your new starting TE and Paul Freedman the backup. Hopefully we don't have to go past that. Coach London said he's keeping the redshirt on the other tight ends, Swanson and McGee, but that's not for the sake of the redshirt. They're simply too small, still.

- As I mentioned yesterday, Morgan Moses moves over to right guard to back up B.J. Cabbell; that position will almost certainly see a changing of the guard (HAW!) by the end of the year. Probably sooner rather than later, as the depth chart lists an "or." Luke Bowanko is now listed as a backup tackle. Sean Cascarano and Oday Aboushi are the starters; who gets what side isn't really settled yet but for the purposes of this chart it doesn't matter.

This youth movement, by the way, I regard it as a huge positive. That's three members of the '09 recruiting class (Cascarano, Bowanko, Aboushi) in the O-line two-deep. Four if you count Moses.

*******************************************

....newsy stuff.

- The mens' swim team opened the season with a huge dual meet win over Florida, and the women came within two points of achieving the same. Impressive. Florida's mens' team took 5th last year (UVA was 10th) and their women were national champions. Even with a loss, the womens' result is as impressive as the mens'; a two-point margin becomes at least a tie just by switching any finish in any race with the opposing swimmer one spot higher.

- UVA hasn't announced it, but UConn has: a 2016-2017 home-and-home rematch with the Huskies. The future schedules page is duly updated.

- The NCAA violation train pulled into Chapel Hill Station this week and left with three of their better players: D-linemen Marvin Austin and Robert Quinn and WR Greg Little, off the team permanently. This week is Carolina week, so I'll probably stop caring after Saturday until the sanctions come down from on high, but here is the official roundup of their player status as it stands now:

Out for good: Austin, Quinn, Little, S Jonathan Smith
Reinstated: RB Shaun Draughn, S Da'Norris Searcy, S Deunta Williams
Suspended: CB Kendric Burney, who returns after the UVA game
Pending, still out: DE Mike McAdoo, DE Linwan Euwell, RB Ryan Houston, CB Charles Brown, S Bryan Gupton, FB Devon Ramsey

Carolina has proven competitive without this bunch of miscreants, so I don't expect to see any huge advantage for UVA this weekend. What you've seen is what you get, and they're 3-2.

*******************************************

....senior seasons:

- Fork Union 27, St. Christopher's 10: Loss for Thompson Brown.

- Petersburg 30, Matoaca 18: Kevin Green throws for two touchdowns and 189 yards, as well as 3 2PCs, in a win.

- Hermitage 34, Mills Godwin 7: Win for Diamonte Bailey, but he doesn't make the article.

- L.C. Bird 48, Cosby 7: Anthony Harris throws one touchdown to help in the win.

- I.C. Norcom 26, Maury 3: Little bit of a closer game than usual for Kameron Mack's team.

- Phoebus 44, Kecoughtan 0: It stays easy for Caleb Taylor, though.

- Green Run 33, Kempsville 13: Win for David Dean.

- Hampton 77, Heritage 0: Holy shit. With David Watford at the helm, Hampton scored on every possession of the first half. Heritage has scored three points all season long.

- Salem 19, Cox 0: Ross Burbank and his offense get shut out.

- Blue Ridge 42, St. S/St. A 28: Loss for Darius Lee, but he catches a touchdown pass.

- Denbigh 28, Menchville 17: Tough season continues for Clifton Richardson.

- DeMatha 31, Good Counsel 28: It hasn't been a season quite up to snuff for Jordan Lomax, Kelby Johnson, and DeMatha, but what better way to get back on track than with a huge, huge win over Vincent Croce and Good Counsel?

- Stone Bridge 56, Fairfax 0: Rob Burns has been helping produce shutout after shutout.

- H.D. Woodson vs. Spingarn, postponed.

- Damascus 49, Watkins Mill 21: Brandon Phelps is still undefeated.

- Providence 38, Independence 27: Loss for Adrian Gamble.

- STAB 14, Boys' Latin 10: Marco Jones visits Charlottesville and gets his first loss of the season for his efforts.

- Mt. Lebanon 31, Baldwin 21: Tim Cwalina also continues undefeated.


*******************************************

....AP poll study update. I've created a new page wherein all the weekly updates are stored; if you're interested, it resides here. Also, it'll be linked on the side with the other useful stuff. This week, there's a slight uptick in evidence for regional bias, but it's still not as convincingly strong as it should be if there's to be a conclusion in favor of the hypothesis.

Tomorrow: the return of the ACC Roundtable!

ongoing AP poll study

My ongoing project for the current football year is this: to determine if there is any regional bias affecting the Associated Press Top 25 rankings. My interest was piqued when I read the AP's guidelines to its voters, which include telling them expressly not to include such a bias in their ballot. It seems like they shouldn't have to be told that; I suspect that guideline exists to calm the public, which harbors a suspicion.

This page is the storehouse for the weekly results as I publish them. If you're unfamiliar with what I'm doing, this page is a must-read in order to understand the charts below. Keep in mind these come out a week after the rankings they analyze.

Week of 9/11:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 9/18:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 9/25:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 10/2:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 10/9:


Overvotes



Averages



Week of 10/16:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 10/23:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 10/30:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 11/6:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 11/13:


Overvotes



Averages



Week of 11/20:

Overvotes



Averages



Week of 11/27:

Overvotes



Averages

Monday, October 11, 2010

that can't happen

I know it's a rebuilding project, yes. I know the talent level on this team isn't where it should be to compete for the ACC. I still didn't like what I saw on Saturday. Rebuilding isn't the same thing as building from scratch. You have to have something to build from, otherwise you're Georgia State, starting fresh and with no expectations whatsoever. I'd like to think that for UVA, that's the defense. That's what's supposed to hold firm and give the team a chance to win while the offense finds its bearings.

Despite an offensive performance that I'd call "almost adequate," the roles were reversed on Saturday. Georgia Tech is a mistake-prone team this year; those mistakes were the only thing standing between them and 50 points. Only under circumstances involving the phrase "I-AA" should the grinding, clock-chewing GT offense be a 50-point machine. I have no idea whether to pin the performance on the players or the coaches, which probably means it's a combination of both. I do know that the decision to open up a fifteen-foot gap at the line of scrimmage was a coach thing, and why Jim Reid would choose to do that against a triple option offense where option #1 is "hand off to a big-ass fullback and let him go in a straight line" is more puzzling than a 10x10 Rubik's Cube.

I've said repeatedly I don't think the 4-3 is a great matchup for that offense, and obviously in order to beat GT in the future either the talent level is going to have to vastly improve relative to GT, or Reid is going to have to scheme his brains out. It's not just scheme: the newness of our OLBs to their position was painfully obvious, and the MLBs were slow to get outside the blockers, leaving them easy targets to get sealed off the pursuit early on.

As for the offense, it wasn't awful, actually. Against FSU and USC I brushed off the last touchdown of the game as a product of less effort on defense and going against the scrubs; this time I'm willing to put that caveat aside because Matt Snyder was covered as hell on the two fine catches he made on the final drive and showed off some white-guys-can-jump moves that I didn't think he had. Whereas the FSU game might as well have been 34-7, I think the 21 points are legitimate.

Still, the running game, as ever, stunk. Hard. Perry Jones was bottled up except for the one run. With Verica, it's like he wasn't even a factor - an improvement over the FSU game, to be sure, and probably about as good as anyone can expect given the four sacks and lack of ground support. Losses always give a megaphone to the BACKUP QB NOWZ crowd that exists in every losing team's fanbase, but Verica's performance was the result of the poor play around him, not the other way round.

As we knew before the season, it starts on the O-line, the least effective group we have. This week you're starting to see the changes you'd expect for a unit with that label: Morgan Moses moves inside to guard, to back up B.J. Cabbell, and Sean Cascarano replaced the injured Landon Bradley at left tackle. Though this is presented a certain way by Mike London, seasoned football observers should be able to read the writing on the wall here: Cabbell's days as the starter there are probably numbered, and Bradley is likely to be Wally Pipped out of his job as well. That's not even to mention the loss of Joe Torchia for the season, ending his UVA career. Torchia has never been a very effective blocker, and his wonky shoulder almost certainly has a big say in that. It's a rebuilding project. You can't expect things to stay much the same as the season rolls on, and these are welcome changes with the exception of the premature end to a career.

These two losses make the UNC game a pivotal one. Bowl hopes, if you harbor any, depend on it. That's a team not unlike GT: doing the best they can with heavy personnel losses, and being competitive with what's left. I hope the GT game was simply a result of a bad matchup, but do you see how the narrative is changing here? It's how seasons go downhill and it's an old, old story: you go from confidently believing that misfortune was the result of something easily fixed, to hoping it, to realizing it wasn't. A good showing against UNC - that is, a win, not a plucky loss - can reverse that. Otherwise, there's little left to fall back on but the baseline "oh well, it was a rebuilding year," and that's no fun.

Sunday, October 10, 2010

blogpoll ballot, week 6: the DAMMIT edition

It's ballot time. In the interest of furthering transparency of this thing, today you get some insight into the process behind this thing. After the ballot, read on to find out what goes on behind the scenes to produce the ballot on a weekly basis.



LSU on top, eh? Yup. They don't get a single first-place vote in the mainstream media polls and they probably won't get any others in the Blogpoll either. Even more surprising is that LSU has traditionally been my whipping boy on my ballot: the last two years I always ranked them well below where they ended up in both the Blogpoll and the MSM ones, because their resume was really weak and I felt they were getting advanced on their name alone. They went 8-5 in 2008, so I was very justified in my skepticism. This year, they're getting bashed for sliding past opponents in ugly fashion, but this isn't a beauty contest.

This year, they're the only team on that ballot who hasn't played a patsy. (They're coming up, to be sure: McNeese State is next week.) But they haven't even gone outside the BCS, for chrissake. The worst team on their schedule is Tennessee. Think about that. Tennessee is really bad, yes, but that's a relative term: they're not New Mexico Bad. And LSU just won at Florida. Undefeated and zero cupcakes: that's a #1 recipe.

Edit: 2nd iteration here which flip-flops FSU and Michigan.

Now for that look into the process. This is very scientific, believe it or not.

Step 1: Identify the 30-35 teams in contention for a ranking. This is subjective, but still pretty obvious. If there's a hint of an idea that I might rank a team, I include them. There are (currently) 15 other teams on a wait list of sorts that I know would never pass muster but might in the future if they continue to win. Some teams (UCLA, Texas) dropped out of the rankings onto the wait list, some played their way on (Syracuse, Mississippi State.) If they're at least 4-2, they're on there, waiting.

Step 2: Take the teams in contention (this week there were 30, and for the record, the teams that didn't make it are - in order - West Virginia, Miami, Air Force, Kansas State, and USC) and scan their resumes. I rank their games from 1 to X (six, this week) from most impressive to least impressive. Here, losses always rank below wins, no matter how bad the win or good the loss. Teams with byes have those placed in the middle on odd weeks and one below halfway on even weeks (so, 4th this week.)

Step 3: This is the longest. Take all the 1st-ranked games from each of the 30 teams and rank them 1-30. 1 point for the best win, 30 for the worst. This week, #1 is South Carolina's win over Alabama and #30 is Air Force's 14-6 win over Navy last week. Most teams by now have at least one pretty good skin on their wall. Repeat this process for each set of games from 1 through 6.

To give you an idea how I look at these, here are these rankings for the 5th- and 6th-most (that is, least) impressive games for the 30 teams.


A few guidelines I follow when I'm ranking these:

- Here, you'll note, losses don't always come after wins. Crummy wins, like South Carolina's ugliness against Furman or Nebraska's lame attempt against South Dakota State don't rank as high as, say, Arkansas's near-miss against Alabama.

- It seems silly to try and decide whether it's more impressive to beat Western Carolina 48-7 or Northwestern State 65-21. I do, however, consider it better to blow out a I-A team than a I-AA team, except in rare cases. And defense is appreciated. Also, once above about 45-50 points, there isn't much consideration to getting even more points. If Team A and Team B both play Cupcake C, and Team A wins 42-0 and Team B wins 69-17, Team A's win is the more impressive in my book because of defense.

- This low in the game rankings, any win against an even slightly respectable opponent (Vandy and Cincy, as you'll note) ranks higher than blowing out a cupcake.

- I always look very, very poorly on being the cupcake, even if to a top-five opponent. FSU's hideous loss to Oklahoma (and I don't care that it was on the road) has cost them several spots on my ballot. They could be as high as 12th or 11th had they put up a decent fight like Air Force did.

This can be a subjective step, and it usually takes some shuffling before I'm happy with the rankings. But the advantage is that I don't know who played about three-quarters of the games on there. So while it's ultimately kind of a subjective way to come up with an objective ballot, it's also mostly anonymous. When I'm ranking those games, I honestly don't very often think, "OK, that's Arkansas who played that game." I have no idea which team came in first or second or anything until I take the next step. LSU was honestly a complete surprise, because I expected it would be Oklahoma or Oregon.

- Step 4: Just tally up the points. You get 1 point for having the best game of the 30, 2 points for the next, etc. I just add these up, and the lowest total is #1 on the ballot. Easy.

- Step 5: What I call divine intervention. Sometimes the science turns up wacky results and I have to move teams up or down because their end ranking is basically indefensible. Maybe because of inconsistencies in ranking the games, but for whatever reason, it ain't perfect. If I can justify where a team is, I leave them, but this week, Michigan State ended up 3rd. That's insane. They deserve a high ranking (barf barf barf) but I had to drop them far enough to get below Stanford, on account of their respective handling of their common opponent, Notre Dame.

There you have it. Better transparency than even the AP poll. Far better. Are you ever going to get Pete DiPrimio to explain why he has been the only #1 vote for Boise State for the whole season? Going to see Jon Wilner's reasoning behind the absolute insanity of his Oregon-State-at-10th vote? No, you are not. (I'll tell you about Wilner: the AP poll study has not found a strong indication or pattern of regional bias, except on the West Coast, where the writers upvote the local teams like crazy motherfuckers. Fresno State knocks off Cincinnati and suddenly they're top-20 stuff, when the rest of the country knew Cincy was a paper tiger. Just wait til the end of the season - I think the results will be interesting, if they keep going the way they're going.)

Anyway. Ballot. Comment. Do it. Also, a note on programming: things are bumped back a bit - tomorrow you'll finally see my take on the GT game (sneak peek: I didn't like it) and then the normal Monday weekend review post will run on Tuesday.

Thursday, October 7, 2010

game preview: Georgia Tech

Date/Time: October 9, 3:30 PM

TV: ESPNUVA

History against the Yellow Jackets: 16-15-1

Last matchup: GT 34, UVA 9; 10/24/09 in Charlottesville

Last week: FSU 34, UVA 14; GT 24, WF 20

Line: Georgia Tech by 10

Opposing blogs: From The Rumble Seat

Uniform combination: blue jersey, orange pants

Injury report:

OUT

WR Bobby Smith
WR Tim Smith
TE Joe Torchia

DOUBTFUL - none

QUESTIONABLE

FB Terence Fells-Danzer
C Mike Price

PROBABLE

OT Landon Bradley
WR Kris Burd
LB Darnell Carter
RB Raynard Horne
WR Brian Oden
TE Colter Phillips

Other useful stuff:
GT season preview
FTRS Q&A
Other half
Updated depth chart

Is this the biggest game of the season? No, but ask around and you'll find a faction of the fanbase that wants this one more than any other this year. Any other. In some circles, the game discussion starts and ends with two words: Al Groh. Tech's Paul Johnson hired Groh to install his 3-4 defense, and the results have been mixed so far, giving UVA fans plenty of reason to believe in the chance of beating the ex-head coach.

HOW WE CAN WIN

- Groh is Groh. You think Al Groh will throw what the FTRS boys call the Grohfense out the window for the UVA game? Detractors and defenders alike can agree on this: Groh doesn't mix things up for the sake of it. He brought what he knows to Georgia Tech, which means they'll be running exactly the same defense UVA ran for nine years. The same defense Mike London ran as defensive coordinator. You know where I'm going with this.

- Big-time safety help on run defense. GT's passing game has been ineffective all season. Joshua Nesbitt is completing passes at under a 40% clip, and the wide receivers have caught just 15 of Nesbitt's 25 completions for an average of 10.9 yards a catch. That's a far cry from 2009 when Demaryius Thomas was the passing game, and averaged over 25 YPC. Bottom line: there's nothing scary about Tech's receivers Stephen Hill and Tyler Melton, and I'm totally happy to let Ras-I Dowling and Chase Minnifield deal with them and cheat the safeties up to help in run support. The corners should be instructed to stick with their receivers - Dowling and Minnifield make one of the best CB tandems in the league and should have little trouble - and the safeties should crash the line of scrimmage and focus on stopping the run.

HOW WE CAN LOSE

- Predictability. So London knows the GT defense. Yup, and Al Groh knows the UVA offense. He even feels confident enough to point out to the media that UVA still (despite the many coordinator changes and the head coaching change) runs a lot of the same stuff Groh ran for Billy McMullen. This is the same style of offense Groh likely preferred. Groh is a wizard on defense, and if Bill Lazor allows UVA to fall into too many patterns, it'll get shut right down. GT's defense may have trouble executing but there's something about knowing what's coming that makes that problem go away.

- Changing to the 4-3 defense. Yes, I worry about this. The 3-4 is uniquely able to deal with Johnson's triple option. Because it already demands the use of a big nose tackle that can clog the middle, it can take away the middle option just by being itself, and with fewer players. That leaves more players to roam the edges, spy the QB and RB, and shut down the running game. It can turn those consistent four- and five-yard gains into one- and two-yarders. The 4-3, being what the majority of college teams play, is what this offense was designed to attack. London and Jim Reid need to find a way to neutralize this inherent advantage. Especially if they're going to insist on using a 245-pound defensive tackle.

- Poor passing game. Nothing invigorates the GT offense more than the ability to dominate in time-of-possession, and nothing facilitates that kind of domination like three-and-outs on offense brought about by incomplete passes. An efficient, well-run passing game won't guarantee victory here, but an inaccurate outing by Verica will likely guarantee a loss.

HOW THE GAME WILL GO

I like UVA's chances a lot better without Rodney McLeod - or any of the defensive backs for that matter - on the injury report. I tell ya though: for all that we didn't know about this team following the first three games, we don't know much more after the fourth. It doesn't help that GT is still kind of a work in progress themselves. The Jackets' offense isn't a high-powered Ferrari - it's more like a smooth four-cylinder engine with insanely good gas mileage. Only, one of the cylinders is misfiring, thanks to the lack of a wide receiver to make the passing game go. Mileage may vary. And the switch to the 3-4 is a big shift, as far as these things go. Not quite on the scale of Rich Rodriguez bringing the ninja spread to one of the Big Tenniest of Big Ten schools, but the growing pains are similar at Tech.

Remember, Wake Forest is one of the conference's worst teams, and Tech barely beat their 4th-string quarterback. So this is not the GT of the past two years. Still: we have our own growing pains, and it's still a safe bet that the offense will still have more bad times than good on Saturday.

So....what? Very few outcomes would surprise me on Saturday. GT is a team ripe for a blowout and you know how UVA teams of late have pulled surprise blowouts out of their asses when least expected. So even with that, I'd just shrug and chalk it up to a developing pattern. I'm feeling too wishy-washy about this game to make an actual prediction, so let's put it this way: the outcome that would not-surprise me the most would be a close loss. We're on the road, after all.

REST OF THE ACC

Virginia Tech vs. Central Michigan, 12:00
Boston College @ NC State, 12:00
Clemson @ North Carolina, 3:30
Wake Forest vs. Navy, 6:30
Florida State @ Miami, 8:00
Duke, Maryland: bye week